The Book of Speculation

The Book of Speculation

Book - 2015
Average Rating:
Rate this:
Simon Watson, a young librarian on the verge of losing his job, finds a mysterious book that holds the key to a curse that has haunted a family of traveling circus performers for generations.
Publisher: New York : St. Martin's Press, 2015.
Edition: First edition.
ISBN: 9781250054807
Branch Call Number: FIC SWYLER, ERIKA
Characteristics: viii, 339 pages ; 25 cm


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment

JessicaGma Mar 12, 2018

I liked the story but I get where others have said this isn't quite a cracking read. Despite that, I did find the characters compelling. Simon is unable to let go of the past for many good reasons, although his sister Enola is better at letting go (for the most part). How the story ties together is quite surprising, and yet not, which suits this tale.

Aug 17, 2017

Simon is sort of hanging on to his heritage; living in his ancestral home that is swiftly crumbling into the sea, reluctantly in love with his childhood friend/next door neighbor, and directionless as far as the future goes -- an issue since he had to be laid off from his job in the library. He receives a mysterious old book in the mail one day, and is launched into an exploration of his family's history with traveling circuses. his mother was the last of a long line of "mermaids," performers who could hold their breath for a very, very long timed. The book appears to be a journal, one of the traditional records of traveling circuses from long ago. From it, he learns that on a particular day, every female in his family for generation have drowned, despite all being "mermaids" and thus excellent swimmers and breath-holders. Simon wants to keep this from happening to his sister, and the particular drowning day is just around the corner.

There's a love story woven into this book, and a mystery, and a touch of supernatural tarot magic. I enjoyed it, but it just didn't bring anything special to the experience of reading it. It wasn't a "page-turner;" the prose didn't sing; I was interested in what would happen next and what would eventually happen, but only mildly. It was a bit too dark to be considered light reading, but it really only skirted the darkness. I enjoyed it but would not recommend it.

coloradobuck Feb 21, 2017

If you are not into tarot cards and a ton of mentioning about death and curses, I would pass on this book although the "holding your breath under water" parts as well as the family piece of the novel were were endearing.

colleenb Jan 02, 2017

This book reminded me of all the elements of John Irving that I love. Worth a read.

JCLKatieS Jul 29, 2016

If my house was falling in and I had lost my job and my long-lost sister appeared out of the blue, I don't think I would become entranced in an old book about a traveling circus that mysteriously appeared on my doorstep. But that's exactly what Simon Watson does and the story that unfolds is magical. You won't be disappointed with this novel - I highly recommend it.

Jul 02, 2016

A rich read. Incredible use of language and imagery, a glimpse into a world that is far beyond the 9 to 5 most of us experience.

Cynthia_N Jun 23, 2016

Enjoyable read! I like the way Library Journal described it in their review, "creates a melancholy world with hints of magic at the edges." The massive amounts of horseshoe crabs on the shore was just an added oddity for me!

Jun 23, 2016

For readers that enjoyed Geek Love by Katherine Dunn, this book is for you. Infused with magic realism, the book takes the reader through a cursed family history. A wonderful glimpse into carnival history as well as a fun read for bibliophiles.

CMLReads_Kristin May 02, 2016

Circus mermaids, tarot card readers, and librarians intertwine in this tale shot through with magic realism. Alternating between the a late eighteenth century traveling carnival and a present day librarian trying to unravel his past, this will appeal to those who like historical narratives that follow families across generations.

cmlibrary_anickerson Mar 28, 2016

Predictable, but spellbinding for the most part. A dark tale, don't look to bond to any of the characters.

View All Comments


Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at SMPL

To Top